Today, I look at what is, in my opinion, one of the more overrated Oscar nominees this year.
American Sniper:
Chris Kyle is known as the most deadly sniper in American history, with 160 confirmed kills. The film chronicles his several tours in Iraq, trying to find a deadly enemy sniper named Mustafa, as well as just stay alive. The film also shows us his crumbling personal life and how it is negatively affected by the war.
This has to be one of the more divisive films of the past year. I was intrigued when I first saw the trailers, thinking it could be a comeback project for Clint Eastwood, who has been on the decline in terms of quality over the past few years. After
Invictus, his films started to become needlessly slow and boring.
J. Edgar and
Jersey Boys are snoozers with little emotional appeal or anything special or memorable about them.
American Sniper is only slightly better. After hearing all the controversy about the film, I deduced there were two distinct schools of thought about it: it is horrific wartime propaganda that idolizes a ruthless killer and general asshole, or: a breathtaking and harsh look at the horrors of war that presents a very human main character. I had to make my own decision, and although I feel both these opinions are extremes, I think I fall more into the first school of thought.
Now, I will not retread all the historical inconsistencies and inaccuracies here, but I will link a video below which covers all that stuff. To get the good stuff out of the way, Bradley Cooper's performance is impressive, and shows that he can do more than comedy and action films. His breakdown at the bar after finishing a tour of duty feels real and is gut-wrenching, and his general reactions to things after the war range from unsettling to just uncomfortable. One problem is that towards the end, the filmmakers decided to randomly "cure" Kyle's PTSD. They never say that, but he just randomly is able to be a better person. I also felt the ending could have been executed better, but I won't spoil it. The only problem is that I think people going into the film need to realize you need to treat Chris Kyle in the film as a fictional character; he is not an accurate representation of the man. The rest of the cast, including Sienna MIller and Luke Grimes, as well as cameos from Aidan Gillen (
Game of Thrones, The Wire) and Brando Eaton (Jonah Mitchell from
Dexter), are fine, but feel like they take a backseat.
The war scenes are very intense and realistic, which I appreciated. They never felt too confusing nor too exploitive, and they are filmed very smoothly and efficiently, although I didn't appreciate the "bad guys vs. good guys" level of complexity in them, nor the constant use of racial insults, like referring to citizens as "savages".
The cinematography isn't anything special, and a lot of the scenes are somewhat predictable (one PTSD moment at a barbecue was extremely cliche) and the music is very bland. There are many plot lines (one involving a fictitious terrorist called "The Butcher", and another involving Kyle's brother) that are set up and just go nowhere. I guess life is like that, too, but the entire film is building up to moments that just never happen.
American Sniper is an entertaining and sometimes gripping film that takes a realistic look at the Iraq War. Though it is a little sanitized as far as the characters go, I still found it better than Eastwood's last few films. I still recommend not taking the film as gospel and looking into the real story a little more; you may be shocked by what you find. Overall, it is an above average movie that I feel doesn't really deserve the hype or the nominations, except maybe for Cooper's performance. I'm going to give this film two ratings, one for accuracy and one for its' quality as a film.
Quality as a film: 3/5 stars.
Accuracy: 1/5 stars.
A video summing up my problems (Spoilers):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ej_SRJNz9ls

(Image: Wikipedia)
End of the Year List Update:
I usually do some "Top (Blank) Of The Year" lists around this time of year, but this time I am doing it a little differently. I decided since I still haven't seen many of the films I wish to see this year, I will take a page out of YourMovieSucks' book, and refrain from doing a list until I have seen said films. Just to show how many I have yet to see, here are a few I still have not seen:
The Imitation Game
Selma
Oculus
Snowpiercer
Leviathan
Magic in the Moonlight
Under the Skin
Top Five
St. Vincent
The Guest
Cold July
Chef
The Raid 2
Jadarowsky's Dune
This Is Where I Leave You
A Most Violent Year
Kill The Messenger
And that's not even the whole list. So it might be a while before you see any such list, although you may see a "Worst of the Year" list sooner.